Medical Malpractice Cases in Australia: Famous Examples and Client Case Studies
Australia is home to one of the world’s best healthcare systems. But even here, mistakes can and do happen. In fact, medical error is one of the leading causes of death worldwide. In Australia alone, it’s estimated that around 18,000 people die each year due to medical malpractice, while another 50,000 suffer a permanent injury.
If you’ve experienced an illness, injury, or poor outcome because a medical professional failed to provide proper care, you may have a medical malpractice claim. It’s also known as a ‘medical negligence’ claim.
A successful claim doesn’t just cover your medical bills. It can also provide compensation for lost income, rehabilitation, long-term care, and your pain and suffering.
To help you understand what a claim might involve and what kind of outcomes are possible, we’ve prepared this case study guide. You’ll read examples from our own clients alongside some of the largest and most significant medical malpractice cases in Australian history. We’ll also explain how to know if you have a claim and how much compensation you could receive.
What is a medical malpractice claim?
Before we jump into examples of medical malpractice cases, let’s start with some basics.
Medical malpractice occurs when a doctor, hospital, or other healthcare provider delivers treatment below a reasonable standard, and you’re harmed as a result. Some of the most common medical malpractice cases include:
- Surgical and anaesthesia errors: such as operating on the wrong body part, leaving instruments inside a patient, or administering incorrect anaesthetic doses.
- Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis: failing to identify a condition or making the correct diagnosis too late.
- Medication mistakes: prescribing the wrong drug or dosage, or overlooking dangerous interactions.
- Pregnancy complications or birth injuries: failing to monitor mother or baby properly or mishandling complications.
- Aftercare failures: discharging patients too early, neglecting post-op monitoring, or managing recovery poorly.
- Failure to warn of risks: not explaining the potential dangers of a procedure or treatment.
Importantly, this isn’t a complete list — just some of the medical malpractice cases we’ve helped our clients win over the years. If you’ve been injured by a medical professional’s poor treatment, you may be entitled to compensation.
Keep reading to see recent cases of medical malpractice we’ve successfully handled. If you’d prefer to chat with an expert lawyer now, just get in touch. Your first consultation is completely free.
Real medical malpractice cases from our clients
Young father wins $10 mil for severe surgical negligence
Sam was a healthy, working father before surgery went wrong. Errors by hospital staff left him with severe neurological impairment, unable to walk, speak, or swallow. His wife had no choice but to become his full-time carer, forcing her to give up work and leaving the family without income.
This was one of the worst cases of medical malpractice our lawyers had seen, and we were determined to secure Sam and his family the full compensation they deserved.
With support from top medical experts, we put together a detailed case showing how the hospital had failed Sam. Though the hospital fought hard against the allegations, our lawyers used strong evidence to rebut each of their defences. After tough negotiations, the case was resolved at mediation for $10 million. This substantial settlement funds Sam’s ongoing care and provides financial security for his family.
After a major firm rejected Rebecca’s claim, we secured her $4.5 mil
Rebecca was hospitalised with an infection that developed into a pulmonary embolism and nerve damage, leaving her paraplegic. Despite a national law firm telling her she had no case, we stepped in just before her time limit expired and fought on her behalf.
Working with reports from top medical experts, our lawyers proved the extent of her injuries and detailed her long-term needs. At mediation, we secured Rebecca a $4.5 million settlement, ensuring she has the care, comfort, and financial security she was nearly denied.
Start your free online claim check
Find out if you’re eligible for a medical malpractice claim today.
Amy wins $2.5 mil for surgery malpractice despite being warned of the risks
After surgery to remove her ovaries and fallopian tubes, Amy suffered a perforated bowel that left her wheelchair-bound and unable to work.
While she was told the risk beforehand, we used expert medical reports to prove the hospital failed to take proper precautions or detect the perforation during the procedure. Our lawyers then built a strong case showing the full extent of Amy’s injuries and directly linking them to the hospital’s negligence.
Through strategic negotiations, we resolved Amy’s case during out-of-court mediation, saving her the stress and expense of court. In the end, we secured $2.5 million to cover her ongoing care, financial needs, and part of her legal fees.
Midwife and hospital pay $2.5 mil for birth injury leading to cerebral palsy
At birth, Nadia was deprived of oxygen and failed to cry or move. A doctor diagnosed her with cerebral palsy at 18 months old. Nadia’s mother had long suspected that hospital negligence was to blame for her daughter’s condition.
When she came to us with her suspicions, our lawyers investigated and confirmed that the midwife and other staff had ignored signs of foetal distress and delayed intervention during the birth.
Armed with this evidence, plus extensive support from birth trauma and cerebral palsy experts, we built a strong case against both the hospital and the midwife. This detailed approach paid off, and Nadia and her mother were awarded a $2.5 million settlement plus legal costs. This outcome ensures Nadia has the financial support she needs for lifelong care and stability.
Esther secures $1.5mil after hospital fails to find cancer
Esther went to a public hospital with severe groin pain, but despite undergoing ultrasounds and x-rays, the staff failed to detect a suspicious mass. This delay meant her rare, aggressive cancer was diagnosed too late, forcing her to undergo intensive treatment and leaving her with permanent health complications.
To prove the hospital’s negligence, our lawyers conducted extensive investigations with other hospitals. This showed that similar facilities would have investigated further and acted on the suspicious imaging results. We then used expert medical evidence to link the delay in diagnosis to her worsened prognosis.
In the end, we secured a $1.5 million settlement to cover Esther’s treatment costs, lost income, and future care needs.
Do I have a case for medical malpractice?
You may have a legal case for medical malpractice if you suffered poor treatment at the hands of a medical professional, and suffered some sort of injury or financial harm as a result.
To win a medical malpractice case, you need to prove three basic things:
Medical malpractice can happen in two ways: through action or inaction. An action might be something like a surgical mistake, while inaction could be a failure to diagnose or treat a condition properly.
To decide if malpractice has occurred, courts use the ‘reasonable standard of care’ test. This looks at whether another competent medical professional, with the same training and faced with the same situation, would have acted differently.
Key factors considered in this assessment include:
- Whether accepted medical guidelines and practices were followed.
- Opinions from independent medical experts in the same specialty.
- The context of the treatment provided, including timing and circumstances.
- The patient’s overall health and any pre-existing conditions.
Successful medical malpractice cases require more than just improper treatment: you need to show that your medical professional’s breach of duty directly led to your injury or illness. This involves establishing two key points:
- Your injury or illness was directly caused by the medical professional’s treatment or lack of proper care.
- The injury or illness was a foreseeable outcome of the treatment provided.
Finally, medical malpractice negligence cases require proof that the injury has caused you real harm or loss. This could include medical bills, lost income, or pain and suffering (the effect the injury has had on your daily life and well-being).
Famous examples of medical malpractice cases
These are three famous medical malpractice court cases that made Australian legal history and changed the way we compensate victims of negligence.
Rogers v Whitaker (1992) – Duty to warn about risks
After Ms. Rogers underwent eye surgery to correct a pre-existing condition, she suffered complete blindness in her operated eye. This was a rare (but known) risk that Ms. Rogers claimed her surgeon, Dr. Whitaker, had failed to warn her about.
The court ruled in favour of Ms. Rogers, establishing that medical professionals have a duty to inform patients of all material risks associated with a procedure, regardless of how rare those risks might be. The ruling emphasised that informed consent is not just a formality, but a legal requirement that ensures patients can make decisions about their care with full knowledge of potential outcomes.
The decision also set a precedent for future medical negligence claims, giving patients stronger grounds to pursue compensation when they experience avoidable harm.
Michael Stewart v Metro North Hospital and Health Service (2024) – Compensation must take into account a patient’s individual circumstances
Michael Stewart underwent abdominal surgery at Redcliffe Hospital in 2016. During the procedure, errors occurred that led to severe complications, including a lack of oxygen, which caused brain damage and partial paralysis. As a result, Stewart required extensive ongoing care and support, and his ability to live independently was significantly affected.
The initial claim focused on the hospital’s breach of duty in failing to properly monitor Stewart during surgery. The court awarded him $2.19 million, taking into account his long-term care needs, loss of income, and the significant impact on his quality of life.
Stewart appealed to the High Court, claiming that the amount did not adequately provide for his ongoing care. The Court confirmed that Stewart’s preference for home care over institutional care had been adequately considered in calculating damages. Their decision emphasised that compensation should account not just for medical costs, but also for the patient’s personal circumstances and preferred care arrangements.
Sparks v Hobson; Gray v Hobson (2018) – Relying on another doctor may be a defence to malpractice
Mr. Hobson underwent spinal surgery but suffered serious complications, leaving him paraplegic. The anaesthetist, Dr. Sparks, and the surgeon, Dr. Gray, were initially found negligent because the surgery continued despite warning signs.
On appeal, the court cleared Dr. Sparks, finding he reasonably relied on Dr. Gray to flag any issues. Dr. Gray’s appeal was dismissed, meaning he was still held responsible for the harm.
The case shows how NSW courts apply the ‘peer professional opinion’ defence. It highlights that doctors can avoid liability if their actions align with what a respected group of professionals would consider acceptable, even if the outcome is unfortunate.
For victims of medical negligence, this case is a reminder that it’s crucial to identify every medical professional who may be liable for your poor treatment. This not only ensures you receive the maximum possible payout for your injury, but also protects your right to compensation if a medical professional relies on the peer professional opinion defence.
How much can you win in a medical malpractice case?
Across Australia, the average medical malpractice payout typically falls between $250,000 and $500,000. However, these figures are just a guide. The actual amount you receive will depend heavily on factors like:
- The seriousness of your injury.
- The impact on your daily life and future independence.
- Whether you can return to work.
- Your ongoing treatment needs.
- How clearly the medical provider failed in their duty of care.
- The strength of the evidence supporting your claim.
Depending on your situation, your compensation may cover:
- Lost income: both now and in the future, including superannuation.
- Pain and suffering: compensation for how your injury affects you physically and mentally.
- Care and support: whether from family, friends or a professional. This also includes support if you can no longer care for someone who depends on you.
- Other expenses related to your injury: medical bills, travel costs, or modifications needed at home or to your car.
Example medical negligence payout ranges
- Minor or moderate injuries ($100,000 – $200,000): these are injuries with short-term effects, such as a delayed diagnosis that doesn’t affect the prognosis much.
- Moderate injuries ($250,000 – $750,000): these are slightly more severe injuries, such as a misdiagnosis causing long-term complications or avoidable surgery.
- Severe or catastrophic injuries ($1 – $10 million+): for injuries that lead to permanent disability, brain damage, or the need for 24/7 care, your payout could reach into the millions.
How long does a medical malpractice claim take?
How long your medical malpractice case takes to settle depends on a few factors, like its complexity and how long it takes for your injuries to stabilise. On average, most medical malpractice claims are resolved within 12 to 18 months.
Once we understand the details of your situation, we can give you a clearer estimate of your case timeline.
What percentage of medical malpractice cases are won?
According to the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, around 59% of medical malpractice claims are successful. However, when you work with our specialist medical negligence lawyers, that success rate jumps dramatically to 98%.
We have decades of experience helping people who’ve been harmed by the healthcare system. Our team understands how insurers operate, including the tactics they use to dispute or minimise claims. We know exactly how to gather evidence, work with medical experts, and build a case that clearly demonstrates malpractice.
With our guidance, it’s extremely likely your case will succeed. Not only will you receive the compensation you need for the future, you’ll get justice for yourself and make the medical system safer for all Australians.
